WASHINGTON — President Trump has proposed a record $4.8 trillion budget for the 2021 fiscal year, and while Congress decides what to fund, the document provides a window into the White House's spending priorities.
The president's plan includes about $2 trillion in cuts to safety net programs and student loan initiatives. Those reductions encompass new work requirements for Medicaid, federal housing assistance and food stamp recipients, which are estimated to cut nearly $300 billion in spending from the programs. The budget would also cut spending on federal disability insurance benefits by $70 billion and on student loan programs by $170 billion.
Foreign aid, public broadcasting and environmental programs also get cut under Mr. Trump's proposal. He wants to spend more money on areas like restricting immigration, including an additional $2 billion for his wall along the southern border, and more money to develop state-of-the-art weapons.
Eliminating student loan help
The administration's budget once again calls for eliminating subsidized federal student loans and ending the public service loan forgiveness program, an incentive for teachers, police officers, government workers and other public servants that cancels their remaining federal student loans after a decade of payments. Those proposals were in last year's budget; Congress failed to adopt them.
The budget proposes cutting the Education Department's funding by 7.8 percent, to $66.6 billion. It also calls for reduced work-study funding and the creation of a single income-driven loan repayment program, to replace what has become a confusing jumble of different payment plans. Under the administration's plan, borrowers would pay 12.5 percent of their discretionary income toward their loans, instead of the 10 percent many currently pay.
— Stacy Cowley and Erica L. Green
Major cuts to Medicaid
The budget proposes numerous changes to Medicaid that reduce spending on the health program for the poor and the disabled. Combined with a section of the budget devoted to "health care reform vision," it cuts spending on Medicaid and subsidies for the Affordable Care Act by a combined trillion dollars.
The budget specifies changes that would tend to reduce enrollment in Medicaid and that the Congressional Budget Office has estimated would cause some states to reverse their expansions of coverage to childless adults without disabilities as part of the Affordable Care Act. Many Medicaid beneficiaries would be subjected to work requirements and asset tests, and states would be pressed to verify eligibility for the program more often under the budget's proposals, strategies that have been shown to reduce enrollment even among those who are eligible. States that preserve their Medicaid expansions under the Affordable Care Act would be asked to gradually pay a larger share of the medical bills for those patients.
The budget would also reduce the federal share of spending for all Medicaid patients, by changing rules about how states can offer extra payments to certain health care facilities run by state or county governments, a policy that the administration has already proposed as a regulation. It would reduce a funding stream meant for hospitals that serve a "disproportionate share" of uninsured patients.
The budget also makes some small expansions of Medicaid coverage: It would allow states the option to cover inpatient care for psychiatric care or drug addiction treatment.
— Margot Sanger-Katz
Medicare tweaked but not slashed
For Medicare, which the president has repeatedly pledged to leave untouched, the budget includes more than a dozen proposals to streamline the program and eliminate what the document describes as waste. Altogether, those strategies save around half a trillion dollars over the decade. But the changes do not represent major structural changes to the program that would reduce benefits or limit who would be eligible for the programs. Many of these shifts were included in President Barack Obama's budgets as well.
Among the changes: Doctors would be paid the same price for services, regardless of whether they work for a hospital or a private practice. It also includes an effort to reduce payments to long-term care hospitals for patients after they are discharged from a regular hospital.
The budget suggests, for the first time, allowing Americans over 65 to opt out of Medicare entirely if they wish. And it would allow Medicare beneficiaries enrolled in a high-deductible health plan to set aside more tax-free savings for health expenses.
It also calls on Congress to pass legislation to reduce the prices paid for prescription drugs. Such legislation, should it be developed and passed, would almost certainly cut spending by Medicare, which is among one of the budget's costliest items.
— Margot Sanger-Katz
Amid coronavirus, an attempt to "refocus" the C.D.C.
The president's budget would cut funding for the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention by 9 percent overall. But it would raise funding levels for the center's infectious disease activities. The White House budget said its cuts reflect an attempt to "refocus" the CDC on its core mission of preventing and controlling infectious disease and other emerging public health issues, such as opioids."
The budget also targets specific programs meant to fight particular cancers and prevent common chronic diseases, combining them into smaller, combined funding streams.
— Margot Sanger-Katz
Deep cuts to environmental initiatives
The administration reserved some of its deepest cuts for the Environmental Protection Agency, which would face a 26 percent reduction in funding and the elimination of 50 programs Mr. Trump deemed "wasteful" or duplicative.
That's about the level the administration has moved to cut the E.P.A. in past years, but Congress has typically restored much of the funding. Last year, for example, lawmakers ultimately provided $9.1 billion to the agency, replacing popular programs the administration had tried to eliminate like federal efforts to clean up the Great Lakes and the Chesapeake Bay.
According to 2021 budget documents the Trump administration has proposed $6.7 billion in total E.P.A. spending, which would shrink the agency to funding levels it last saw during the 1990s. A budget summary said the administration aims to prioritize "core functions" like addressing lead exposure in water and revitalizing former toxic cleanup sites. On the chopping block are programs the administration deemed "outside of the E.P.A.'s core mission" like beach cleanup.
The budget does not mention climate change. It also states misleadingly that air pollutant emissions dropped between 2016 and 2018, and credited the Trump administration with overseeing "some of the cleanest air and water in the world" while eliminating clean air and water regulations.
After a decade of improvement in air quality nationally, federal data last year showed that fine particulate pollution has increased in the last two years.
At the same time, the budget promotes a fossil fuel "energy boom" in the United States, including an increase in the production of natural gas and crude oil, both of which release carbon dioxide emissions responsible for warming the planet.
Republicans in Congress this week are preparing to unveil a climate change agenda that focuses heavily on funding for "innovation" — like the development of carbon capture technology to store the planet-warming carbon dioxide that is released from power plants, or batteries to store solar power during periods of low demand. But under Mr. Trump's 2021 budget plan, the Department of Energy, which oversees such federal research, would undergo a 29 percent cut to all programs not related to nuclear weapons and defense.
— Lisa Friedman
Food stamps on the chopping block
The administration once again suggested cutting funds for America's primary food assistance program and continued an effort to reduce the number of adults who can qualify for the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, or SNAP.
The budget reduces SNAP funding by about $180 billion between 2021 and 2030.
The White House has been making changes to the program on its own, including toughening eligibility requirements and cracking down on states that "misuse" work requirement waivers. In keeping with that approach, the budget proposes one set of work requirements for adults ages 18 to 65 who are able to work, rather than making a distinction on whether those adults have children or not. All adults who are able to work would have to engage in "at least 20 hours or more" of work or training in order to qualify for benefits.
The budget also keeps Mr. Trump's controversial "Harvest Box" proposal in place, continuing to suggest that poor Americans who receive SNAP benefits get a portion of their benefit in a "Harvest Box" full of food preselected for nutritional value and economic benefit to American farmers. The cache of cheaper peanut butter, canned goods, pasta, cereal, "shelf stable" milk and other products would now be selected by the federal government, not by the people eating it.
The a White House official said the changes were necessary given that too many Americans remain on public assistance.
"Despite significant economic improvement and a strong job market, participation has not yet declined to prerecession levels, and too many people are still missing the opportunity to move from dependence to self-sufficiency," the budget said.
— Lola Fadulu
Reduced housing assistance
Mr. Trump proposed to again cut funding for the Department of Housing and Urban Development, including programs that help pay for rental assistance for low-income people.
The budget proposes a 15.2 percent decrease in gross discretionary funding from 2020 and eliminates several block grant programs. The administration argues that some of the programs, such as the Community Development Block Grant, are not effective and that the funding could be redirected to other priorities, such as national security. The budget eliminates the Choice Neighborhoods Program, which awards grants to neighborhoods with deteriorating public and federally assisted housing, arguing that states and local governments are better able to revitalize neighborhoods.
Mr. Trump also requested less money for rental assistance programs, such as Housing Choice Vouchers, and proposed that tenants who are able to work and receive assistance contribute 35 percent of their income to rent instead of 30 percent.
— Lola Fadulu
Trade assistance winnowed
The proposed budget slashes discretionary funding for the Commerce Department, which monitors the weather, collects economic data, promotes exports, issues patents and other duties, by more than 37 percent, the largest single cut to any agency. More than half of that decrease, though, was a reflection of decreased spending on the 2020 census, which will not be repeated next year.
The budget also pares money for the trade adjustment assistance program, which is run through the Labor Department. The program offers training and support to workers who have lost their jobs as a result of outsourcing, but it has faced criticism that it may actually end up making its recipients worse off, by temporarily taking them out of the work force for training. The Trump administration has proposed refocusing the program more on apprenticeships and on-the-job training.
The cuts to the Commerce Department budget also include various reductions to economic development programs, which the administration says are duplicated elsewhere.
The budget requests additional funding for investments in areas considered crucial for American competitiveness, particularly advanced technology, including artificial intelligence, quantum computing, advanced manufacturing and 5G telecom networks.
The White House has proposed allowing the Commerce Department to auction off more telecom spectrum to private companies, one of the main bottlenecks in the country's effort to advance 5G. The change would give private companies more access to a scarce resource and generate $670 million over the next 10 years, the administration said.
— Ana Swanson
Crackdown on illegal immigration gets a big boost
Mr. Trump's budget requests $2 billion to build 82 miles of border wall along the border with Mexico, as the Homeland Security Department rushes to complete 450 miles of barriers by 2021. The administration has completed nearly 120 miles thus far, almost all of it on federal land and in areas where there were sections of dilapidated wall or vehicle barriers.
The $2 billion is significantly less than the $5 billion in wall funding that Mr. Trump sought a year ago, which resulted in a five-week government shutdown. While Congress has previously agreed to provide only $1.375 billion for wall construction, Mr. Trump has found a way to secure money for his wall without congressional approval by shifting billions of dollars from military construction projects and programs used to crack down on narcotics activity.
The proposal also includes $182 million to hire 750 Border Patrol agents and build processing centers for agents and another $544 million to hire more than 4,600 Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents and immigration court prosecutors.
The White House budget includes $3.1 billion for 60,000 beds in ICE detention centers, an increase from the 54,000 the White House requested last year. The increase in the budget request shows that the administration is likely to keep working to crack down on illegal immigration in the coming year.
— Zolan Kanno-Youngs
Secret Service returns to Treasury
The White House officially proposed moving the Secret Service from the Department of Homeland Security to the Treasury Department.
Treasury Secretary Steven Mnuchin has been in talks with D.H.S. officials and members of Congress to secure an agreement over legislation that would return Secret Service to Treasury, where it existed ahead of the national security reshuffling that occurred after the Sept. 11, 2001 attacks. The budget argues that moving it would "create new efficiencies" in the investigation of financial crimes and prepare the United States to face "the threats of tomorrow," such as the use of cryptocurrencies to finance terrorism.
There appears to be bipartisan support for the move, but Mr. Mnuchin's unwillingness to provide documents ahead of the 2020 election on what it has cost the Secret Service to protect the president and his family has complicated the effort.
The Trump administration wants to allocate $2.4 billion to the Secret Service, up from $2.3 billion a year ago.
— Alan Rappeport
Foreign aid gets cut
Funding for the State Department and international aid programs would be cut by $3.7 billion, or nearly 8 percent, from current spending levels. It would dramatically reduce or eliminate aid to international organizations, including the United Nations.
The overall $44.1 billion spending proposal does away with discretionary funds for unplanned expenses overseas by the United States Agency for International Development and 12 other agencies that work with the State Department.
It also eliminates funding for a food aid program that officials described as too slow to meet needs, economic and development accounts that impede direct assistance to specific countries in Europe and Asia, and for the Asia Foundation, a nonprofit that boosts good governance and empowers women.
Programs that would receive fewer funds include peacekeeping efforts by the United Nations, which would be cut by $447 million, and the United States' annual contribution to the world body itself, by $508 million.
The Trump administration has long complained that the United States pays 22 percent of the United Nations' annual budget, more than any other country. In 2018, the administration ended funding to the United Nations agency that helps Palestinian refugees and tried to curba peacekeeping mission in southern Lebanon — both as Mr. Trump sought to bolster Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu ahead of elections in Israel.
— Lara Jakes
New York Times, February 10, 2020
###
February 10, 2020
Voices4America Post Script. Who was that man at the State of the Union who said no cuts to Medicare, Medicaid or Social Security? This guy proposed $800 cuts to them. #DuckTrump As @SpeakerPelosi said, pass it on.
Some reactions.
