09 July 2017
PAST POSTSHere is the transcript.
The G20 became the G19 as it ended. On the Paris climate accords the United States was left isolated and friendless.
It is, apparently, where this US President wants to be as he seeks to turn his nation inward.
Donald Trump has a particular, and limited, skill-set. He has correctly identified an illness at the heart of the Western democracy. But he has no cure for it and seems to just want to exploit it.
He is a character drawn from America's wild west, a travelling medicine showman selling moonshine remedies that will kill the patient.
And this week he underlined he has neither the desire nor the capacity to lead the world.
Given the US was always going to be one out on climate change, a deft American President would have found an issue around which he could rally most of the leaders.Given the US was always going to be one out on climate change, a deft American President would have found an issue around which he could rally most of the leaders.
He had the perfect vehicle — North Korea's missile tests.
So, where was the G20 statement condemning North Korea? That would have put pressure on China and Russia? Other leaders expected it and they were prepared to back it but it never came.
There is a tendency among some hopeful souls to confuse the speeches written for Mr Trump with the thoughts of the man himself.He did make some interesting, scripted, observations in Poland about defending the values of the West.
And Mr Trump is in a unique position — he is the one man who has the power to do something about it.
But it is the unscripted Mr Trump that is real. A man who barks out bile in 140 characters, who wastes his precious days as President at war with the West's institutions — like the judiciary, independent government agencies and the free press.
He was an uneasy, awkward figure at this gathering and you got the strong sense some other leaders were trying to find the best way to work around him.Mr Trump is a man who craves power because it burnishes his celebrity. To be constantly talking and talked about is all that really matters. And there is no value placed on the meaning of words. So what is said one day can be discarded the next.
So, what did we learn this week?
We learned Mr Trump has pressed fast forward on the decline of the US as a global leader. He managed to diminish his nation and to confuse and alienate his allies.
He will cede that power to China and Russia — two authoritarian states that will forge a very different set of rules for the 21st century.
Some will cheer the decline of America, but I think we'll miss it when it is gone.
And that is the biggest threat to the values of the West which he claims to hold so dear.
Chris Uhlmann, ABC Australia, July 8, 2017.
###
July 9, 2017
Addendum. As outlined above, Trump's trip to Poland and the G20 was horrific and an embarrassment. This every sentient observer noted.
First, in Poland, he delivered a xenophobic, prepared speech that called for "Western Civilization" to defend itself. His proclaimed enemy once again included "fake news," as he continued his attacks on America's free press.
Then, Trump and his entourage arrived at the G20 in Hamburg in disarray, since that they hadn't even arranged hotel rooms.
Trump's long awaited meeting with the Russian dictator, with whom he seems either involved in conspiracy or bromance, came finally and then it went, since there was little to report about it other than it was long and inappropriately secretive. The one major revelation it offered, which surprised no one, was that Trump seemed to accept Putin's word over that of American Intelligence on the issue of Russian interference with our 2016 election.
Next came a true surprise. With seemingly no awareness or regard for the insult he was perpetuating on the American people and on world leaders, Trump has his daughter Ivanka sit in on several G20 meetings in his place.
During most of the G20 meetings he did attend , Trump simply wandered around haplessly, with no clue as to how to behave or what to talk about or with whom he should talk. In short, during Trump's second disastrous trip abroad, he presented himself as a cipher, where we would normally expect the leader of the free world.
Hence comes Chris Uhlmann's scathing question: Does Trump's awkward performance indicate America's decline as world power? The answer painfully is "yes."